Skip to content

NYPD “Boot-and-Tow” Policy Challenged in Class Action Lawsuit

Klafter Lesser is currently litigating a class action lawsuit that accuses New York City and the NYPD of running an illegal, logistically impossible “boot-and-tow” scheme designed to trap drivers into excessive fees.

The lawsuit, filed by Klafter Lesser LLP, challenges the city’s strict policy regarding booted vehicles. It has been the policy of the NYPD until very recently that once the NYPD boots a car, the owner has just two hours to pay a $185 boot fee at a designated tow pound in the Bronx, Brooklyn, or Queens. If they miss the window, the vehicle is promptly towed, tacking on an additional $185 towing fee for a total of $370.

The lawsuit argues this current system violates NYC law and is unconstitutional. According to the complaint, this policy violates the law in four distinct ways:

  • NYC Traffic Rules (34 TRCNY § 4-08(9)(v)): Denies drivers a reasonable opportunity to challenge the boot before a tow is initiated.
  • Unlawful Seizure:   Towing a vehicle without fair notice or a realistic chance to retrieve it constitutes an unlawful seizure in violation of the 4th Amendment to the US Constitution.
  • Excessive Fines: Stacking the twin $185 fees for a single alleged violation creates an excessive fine in violation of the 8th Amendment to the US Constitution.
  • Due Process: The NYPD fails to inform vehicle owners of their legal right to challenge the fines in violation of the 14th Amendment of the US Constitution.

The Locks Law Firm is co-counsel with KL in this case.

Have a question? Let us know!