For over 30 years, the District of Columbia has denied out-of-state “semi-public” institutions—such as nonprofit scientific, educational, and charitable organizations—the sales and room tax exemptions granted to local D.C. semi-public institutions. Under D.C. Code § 47-2005(3)(C), out-of-state nonprofits hosting or attending meetings at D.C. hotels are forced to pay these taxes simply because they do not maintain a physical office in the District.
In 2017, the American Philosophical Association and the American Anthropological Association launched a class action lawsuit in the Superior Court of the District of Columbia challenging this practice. The plaintiffs allege that this residency restriction violates the Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution, which strictly prohibits jurisdictions from economically discriminating against out-of-state entities. Notably, no other U.S. state imposes a similar residency requirement for tax exemptions.
Case Status and Next Steps
- The Class: The lawsuit represents all out-of-state 501(c)(3) organizations that paid D.C. sales or hotel taxes for qualifying organizational meetings from December 12, 2016, onward.
- The Court’s Ruling: The Superior Court granted summary judgment in favor of the plaintiffs, ruling that the D.C. law is unconstitutional.
- The Judgment: Following four days of evidentiary hearings to resolve disputed damage claims, the Court entered a final Judgment in December 2025 ordering the District to refund the valid taxes collected plus pre-judgement interest.
- Current Posture: The District of Columbia has appealed this Judgment. Appellate briefing is now complete, and the parties are currently awaiting the District of Columbia Court of Appeals to schedule oral argument.